Why does an ice dam start in the attic and not on the roof?
An ice dam needs snow on the upper roof to melt and the eave to stay below freezing. The melt comes from heat that rises from the house into the attic, so the attic controls whether the snow melts at all. The roof covering only decides where the water goes after it has melted.
The University of Minnesota Extension describes the mechanism as upper roof surfaces above 32 degrees Fahrenheit while lower surfaces are below it. The upper roof becomes warm because heat from the house warms the underside of the boards.
Does more insulation alone solve an ice dam?
More insulation helps, but it does not solve the problem alone if air is still leaking from the living space into the attic. Warm moist air moves through gaps even when the insulation is thick, and it warms the boards where the leaks are. Air sealing comes first, then insulation, then ventilation, in the order that makes each step work.
A thick blanket of insulation laid over open gaps still lets warm air rise through the holes around fixtures and hatches. The air carries moisture from the house, and the moisture condenses on the cold boards and can frost them.
What moves the price of attic work up or down?
The price depends on the size of the attic, the number and type of air leaks, how much insulation is needed, and whether the vents are blocked or missing. Access through the hatch, the height of the eave and the condition of the framing also change the work. The price is explained and approved before any work starts.
A small attic with a few leaks and open vents is a short job, while a large attic with many penetrations and blocked eaves takes longer. The number of fixtures, bath fans and plumbing stacks drives the air-sealing work, and each needs its own detail.
How do I know if the attic work is making a difference?
The first sign is less frost and damp on the underside of the boards after the next cold spell. The snow on the upper roof should melt less unevenly, and the icicles at the eave should be smaller or absent. A technician can check the attic and the eave after a winter and tell you what has changed.
Look at the snow on the roof after a snowfall. A roof that is melting unevenly, with bare patches above the living space and snow still lying over the eave, is still losing heat from below.
Can I do the attic work myself?
Some attic work, such as clearing a blocked soffit vent or checking for frost, can be done safely by a homeowner. Air sealing and insulation work near wiring, fixtures and the hatch is best done by someone who understands how the gaps and the heat move. A technician can show you what to check and do the parts that need specialist care.
Work in an attic is done on joists, since insulation hides the ceiling and a foot placed on the drywall will break through. Keep to the path, wear a dust mask and avoid disturbing wiring or fixtures.